This is one of the sole reasons I'm trying DisplayFusion and can't get it to work.

I set the Tasbar options in Settings to "Windows Taskbar shows all Windows, DisplayFusion shows relevant windows."

As the screenshot shows, the Windows taskbar does NOT show all windows, just the ones on that monitor....is this not how it's supposed to work?

Perhaps you could 'Unprotect' the screenshot so we can see it.

Ah, sorry - there we go, I didn't know what that did

Thank you Keith! You're right, the other two are DisplayFusion taskbars, I didn't know because they look the exact same I now have it set on "All taskbars show all windows" and it seems to be working!